The prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test is a simple blood test to screen for prostate cancer. It has been used in men over 50 as a routine part of a physical exam, with levels above 4 ng/mL indicating possible prostate cancer. The test result is not always correct, sometimes indicating prostate cancer when it is not present and often missing prostate cancer that is present. Suppose that these are the approximate conditional probabilities of a positive (above 4 ng/ml) and negative test result given cancer is present or absent. In a large study of prostate cancer screening, it was found that about 6.2% of the population has prostate cancer. Draw a tree diagram for selecting a person from this population (outcomes: cancer present or absent) and testing his blood (outcomes: test positive or negative).

Answers

Answer 1

The missing table for the Test Result can be expressed as:

                              Test Result

                               Positive         Negative

Cancer Present        0.21              0.79

Cancer Absent        0.06              0.94

Answer:

Step-by-step explanation:

A tree diagram is an elegant way of determining an exhaustive list of sample elements in the sample space. It is by finding the ordered n-tuples of the elements in the events under consideration.

The tree diagram for selecting a person from the population in the given question can be found in the attached image below.

The Prostate-specific Antigen (PSA) Test Is A Simple Blood Test To Screen For Prostate Cancer. It Has

Related Questions

the number that are being multiplied are called as.................

Answers

Answer:

Factors

Step-by-step explanation:

Factor*factor=product

Answer:

The numbers to be multiplied are generally called the "factors". The number to be multiplied is the "multiplicand", and the number by which it is multiplied is the "multiplier". ... The result of a multiplication is called a product.

Step-by-step explanation:

What is the value of x for the triangle shown to the right?

What is the value of x for the triangle shown to the right?

Answers

Answer:

x = 6.24

Step-by-step explanation:

x =

Tan32° = OPP/ADJ

Tan32° = x/10

0.624 = x/10

cross-multiply

x = 6.24

If the 4th and 7th terms of a G.P are −1/2 and
− 4, respectively, then find G5 and S6 .​

Answers

Answer:

G5 = -1

S6 = -63/16

Step-by-step explanation:

The formula for finding the nth term of a GP is Tn = ar^n-1

a is the first term

r is the common ratio

n is the number of terms

If the 4th term is -1/2

T4 = ar^4-1

T4 = ar³ = -1/2.... 1

If the 7th term is -4

T7 = ar^7-1

T7 = ar^6 = -4.... 2

Divide both equation

ar^6/ar³ = -4/(-1/2)

r³ = -4×-2

r³ = 8

r = 2

Common ratio is 2

Since ar³ = -1/2

a(2)³ = -1/2

8a = -1/2

a = -1/16

The first term is -1/16

Get the fifth term G5

G5 = ar⁴

G5 = (-1/16)(2)⁴

G5 = (-1/16)(16)

G5 = -1

Get the sum of the first six terms S6

S6 = a(r^n-1)/r-1

S6 = -1/16(2^6-1)/2-1

S6 = -1/16(64-1)

S6 = -63/16

Hence the sum of the first six terms is -63/16

PLS HURRY For the expression 9x^2-8/3x^2+4, which sum represents the correct form of the partial fraction decomposition?

Answers

The partial fraction decomposition of the expression 9x^2 - 8/3x^2 + 4 is \(\frac{9x^2}{3x^2 + 4} - \frac{8}{3x^2 + 4}\)

How to express as a partial fraction?

The expression is given as:

9x^2 - 8/3x^2 + 4

Rewrite properly as follows:

\(\frac{9x^2 - 8}{3x^2 + 4}\)

Split the expression as follows:

\(\frac{9x^2}{3x^2 + 4} - \frac{8}{3x^2 + 4}\)

Hence, the partial fraction decomposition of the expression 9x^2 - 8/3x^2 + 4 is \(\frac{9x^2}{3x^2 + 4} - \frac{8}{3x^2 + 4}\)

Read more about partial fraction decomposition at:

https://brainly.com/question/12783868

#SPJ1

Which system is represented in the graph? y > x2 – 3x + 2y ≥ –x2 + 1 y < x2 – 3x + 2y < –x2 + 1 y ≥ x2 – 3x + 2y ≤ –x2 + 1 y > x2 – 3x + 2y < –x2 + 1

Which system is represented in the graph? y &gt; x2 3x + 2y x2 + 1 y &lt; x2 3x + 2y &lt; x2 + 1 y x2

Answers

Explanation

To find the answer, we will have to find the equations that define the two functions

For the first graph

\(\begin{gathered} let \\ f(x)=a(x+1)(x-1) \\ when\text{ } \\ x=0,\text{ y=1} \\ 1=a(1)(-1) \\ a=-1 \\ Thus \\ y\ge-1(x^2-1) \\ y\ge-x^2+1 \end{gathered}\)

For the second graph (The purple)

\(\begin{gathered} g(x)=a(x-1)(x-2) \\ when\text{ x=0,y=2} \\ 2=a(0-1)(0-2) \\ a=\frac{2}{-1\times-2}=\frac{2}{2}=1 \\ \\ a=1 \\ Thus,\text{ we have} \\ g(x)>1(x-1)(x-2) \\ g(x)>x^2-3x+2 \\ y>x^2-3x+2 \end{gathered}\)

Thus, the answer is

\(\begin{gathered} y\ge-x^2+1 \\ y>x^2-3x+2 \end{gathered}\)

what would be the slope?​

what would be the slope?

Answers

I think 8, because 1/8

 Hey guys, I would really appreciate if one of you help me with this question

 Hey guys, I would really appreciate if one of you help me with this question

Answers

Answer: 28.25%

Step-by-step explanation:

113/400=0.2825=28.25%

A function does not have any x-intercepts. What
might be true about its domain and range?

Answers

The domain exists on all real numbers i.e {x∈R}∈

The range exists all on real numbers except at y = 0

Domains are all input values of a function for which the function exists while ranges are all the output values for which the function exists.

Since the x-intercept of a function exists at where y = 0, this means that the point where a function does not have any x-intercepts are all other points on the graph except at y = 0.

The following statements are therefore true;

The domain exists on all real numbers i.e {x∈R}The range exists all on real numbers except at y = 0

Learn more here: https://brainly.com/question/12648810

Decimals, fractions, and percents can all represent the same values.

True

False

Answers

The given statement that, decimal, fraction, and percent can all represent the same values is True.

Verification of the True Statement:

The ratio of two numbers results in a fraction which are often rational numbers (often integers). As an illustration, 11/59 is a fraction. Typically, absolute values for fractions should be larger than 0 and less than 1. A mixed fraction equivalent to 1 3/4 is 7/4.

A fraction stated in tenths are known as a decimal (or tenths of tenths, etc.). The decimal equivalent of one fourth, or 1/4 as a fraction, is 0.25 (which equals 25/100). (Remember that 1/100 is just a tenth of a tenth.)

Percentage (percent) is a decimal fraction multiplied by 100. Therefore, 0.25 is equivalent to 25 percent, for instance. The ratio of two numbers results in fractions, which are often rational numbers (often integers).

Let us take a number 3/5, this is a fraction.

Now, if we further divide, 3 by 5, we will get 0.6

This 0.6 is a decimal number, but it still represents the number 3/5

Similarly, it is equivalent to 60 percent which again represent the fraction 3/5 or decimal 0.6.

Learn more about a fraction here:

https://brainly.com/question/10354322

#SPJ1

the mass of sugar is 19kg.What is the total mass of 4 such jar of a sugar?​

Answers

Answer: 76kg

Step-by-step explanation:

If the mass of sugar in one jar is 19kg, then the mass of 4 such jars of sugar can be found by multiplying the mass of one jar by 4:

Total mass of 4 jars of sugar = 4 × 19kg Total mass of 4 jars of sugar = 76kg

Therefore, the total mass of 4 jars of sugar is 76kg.

__________________________________________________________

MASS

The mass of sugar is 19 kg. What is the total mass of 4 such jar of a sugar?

Answer:

The total mass of four jars of sugar is 76 kg.

Solution and Explanation:

The total mass of four jars of sugar can be found by multiplying the mass of one jar by 4:

\(\large\rm{Total\: mass = 19\: kg \times 4 = \boxed{\rm{\:76\: kg\:}}}\)

\(\therefore\) The total mass of four jars of sugar is 76 kg.

What is mass?

- Mass is a measure of the amount of matter an object contains. It is a fundamental property of an object and is typically measured in units such as kilograms or grams. Mass is different from weight, which is the force of gravity acting on an object's mass. Mass is an intrinsic property of an object and remains constant regardless of its location, while weight can vary depending on the gravitational field it is in. Essentially, mass determines an object's resistance to acceleration or change in motion.

Learn more about mass here: https://brainly.com/question/30400740

With unique examples of your own let’s discuss the number of solutions possible (0, 1, 2, 3, 4) to a system of equations that include a conic section.

Answers

The number of solutions possible to a system of equations that include a conic section depends on the type of equations involved

How to determine the number of solutions?

A system of equation that has a conic section may or may not have solutions.

It would have a solution if the equations intersect, when plotted on a graph and it would not, if otherwise

A conic section can be any of:

ParabolaEllipseHyperbolaCircle

Example 1: No solution

Consider the following system of equations

y = x² - 10 --- parabola equation(x - 1)² + (y - 2)² = 5 --- circle

The above system of equations has no solution because they do not intersect when plotted on a graph (see graph 1)

Example 2: One solution

Consider the following system of equations

x = 2 --- linear equationy = x² - 10 --- parabola

The above system of equations has one solution because they intersect at one point (see graph 2)

Example 3: One solution

Consider the following system of equations

y = 2x + 1 --- linear equationy = x² - 10 --- circle

The above system of equations has two solutions because they intersect at two points (see graph 3)

The above examples imply that a system of equations that involves conic section can have as many solutions as possible.

The number of solutions depends on the type of equations involved

The attached graphs illustrate how a system of equations can have 0 to 4 solutions

Read more about system of equations at:

https://brainly.com/question/14323743

#SPJ1

With unique examples of your own lets discuss the number of solutions possible (0, 1, 2, 3, 4) to a system

Find the greatest common factor​ (GCF) of 42a3b, 24a2b2, and 24ab3

Answers

Answer:

Hi it is like

Find the greatest common factor​ (GCF) of 42a3b, 24a2b2, and 24ab38

Step-by-step explanation:

the shortest side of a right triangle measures 7m. The lengths of the other two sides are Consecutive integers. What is the length of the other two sides?

Answers

The lengths of the other two sides of the right triangle are 24m and 25m, respectively.

Let's assume the consecutive integers representing the lengths of the other two sides of the right triangle are x and x + 1, where x is the smaller integer. We are given that the shortest side measures 7m. Now, we can use the Pythagorean theorem to solve for the lengths of the other two sides.

According to the Pythagorean theorem, in a right triangle, the square of the length of the hypotenuse (the longest side) is equal to the sum of the squares of the lengths of the other two sides.

Using this theorem, we have the equation:

\(7^2 + x^2 = (x + 1)^2\)

Expanding and simplifying this equation, we get:

\(49 + x^2 = x^2 + 2x + 1\)

Now, we can cancel out \(x^2\) from both sides of the equation:

49 = 2x + 1

Next, we can isolate 2x:

2x = 49 - 1

2x = 48

Dividing both sides by 2, we find:

x = 24

Therefore, the smaller integer representing the length of one side is 24, and the consecutive integer representing the length of the other side is 24 + 1 = 25.

Hence, the lengths of the other two sides of the right triangle are 24m and 25m, respectively.

For more question on lengths visit:

https://brainly.com/question/28322552

#SPJ8

I will give BRAINLIEST!!

21 cm
Find the circumference. Round your answer to the nearest hundredth. Use 3.14 for
Enter the correct answer in the box.

I will give BRAINLIEST!!21 cmFind the circumference. Round your answer to the nearest hundredth. Use

Answers

Answer:

132 cm

I hope this helped!

2.2.PS-16

Challenge Schools A and B are competing in an academic contest. Correct answers earn 9 points.

Incorrect answers lose 2 points. In the final round, School A gives the same number of correct and

incorrect answers. School B gives no incorrect answers and the same number of correct answers as

School A. School A started the final round with 62 points. School B started with 24. The game ends

with the two schools tied. Let x represent the number of correct answers given by School A in the final

round. Write an equation that models the outcome of the contest. Then find the number of answers

that each school got correct in the final round.

Which equation models the scoring in the final round and the outcome of the contest?

OA. 9x + 2x - 62 = - 9x + 24

OB. 2x-9x + 62 = 9x + 24

OC. 9x - 2x - 62 = 9x + 24

OD. 9x - 2x + 62 = 9x + 24

Answers

Answer:

9x - 2x + 62 = 9x + 24

Number of correct answer each obtained = 19

Step-by-step explanation:

Given that:

Number of correct answers = x

POINTS for correct answers = 9

POINTS for incorrect answers = - 2

SCHOOL A:

Number of correct answers = x

Number of incorrect answers = x

Initial point = 62

Initial point + 9(number of correct answers) + - 2(number of incorrect answers)

62 + 9x - 2x

SCHOOL B :

Number of correct answers = x

Number of incorrect answers = 0

Initial point = 24

Initial point + 9(number of correct answers) + - 2(number of incorrect answers

24 + 9x

Since they end up tied :

School A = School B

62 + 9x - 2x = 24 + 9x

9x - 2x + 62 = 9x + 24

Number of correct answers gotten :

9x - 2x + 62 = 9x + 24

7x + 62 = 9x + 24

7x - 9x = 24 - 62

-2x = - 38

x = 19

Hence, Number of correct answers each obtained = 19

Mr. Hooper has a tree in his front yard that grows every year. If the tree was 3 feet tall when he planted it 6 years ago , what is the current height of the tree in terms of f?
A. 3f + 6 feet
B. 6f + 3 feet
C. 3f + 18 feet
D. 6f + 18 feet

Answers

The height of the tree after 6 years can be expressed as "3 feet + 6f feet."

The correct answer is A. 3f + 6 feet.

To determine the current height of the tree in terms of "f,"

let's analyze the given information.

We know that the tree was initially 3 feet tall when it was planted 6 years ago.

Since the tree grows every year, we can assume that its growth rate is consistent.

Let's denote the current height of the tree as "h" (in feet).

After 6 years, the tree has grown by a certain amount, which we'll represent as "6f" (6 years multiplied by the growth rate "f").

Therefore, the height of the tree after 6 years can be expressed as "3 feet + 6f feet."

For similar question on height.

https://brainly.com/question/28122539  

#SPJ8

Since the mode is the most frequently occurring data value, it

Select one:
a. is always larger than the mean
b. can never be larger than the mean
c. must have a value of at least two
d. is always larger than the median
e. None of these answers is correct.


Any answer without justification will be rejected automatically.

Answers

The correct answer is option (e): None of these answers is correct.

The statement "the mode is the most frequently occurring data value" is true. However, none of the options provided accurately describes the relationship between the mode and the mean.

The mode and the mean are different measures of central tendency and can have different values. There is no general rule or guarantee that the mode will always be larger or smaller than the mean. The relationship between the mode and the mean depends on the specific dataset and its distribution. Therefore, none of the provided options correctly describes the relationship between the mode and the mean.

plz help me i need help on this question

plz help me i need help on this question

Answers

Answer:

126

Step-by-step explanation:

125.6 is the true answer, but if we estimate, it'll round up to 126

Please help thank uuuuu

Please help thank uuuuu

Answers

Answer:

12

Step-by-step explanation:

You simply add the coefficients together.
3 + 4 + 5 = 12

Two lines intersect to form 4 angles. Angles 2 and 4 are vertical angles with angle 2 = 4x + 12 and angle 4 = 7x - 6. a) Find x. b) What is the measure of angle 2 ?

Answers

Answer:

Does this help?

Step-by-step explanation:

2 = 4x + 12 and angle 4 = 7x - 6

Use the slope-intercept form to find the slope and y-intercept.

Slope: 0

y-intercept: 4

Use the slope-intercept form to find the slope and y-intercept.

Slope: 0

y-intercept: 2

Use the slope-intercept form to find the slope and y-intercept.

Slope: 0

y-intercept: 4

Graph 2= 4x + 12

Slope: Undefined

y-intercept: No y-intercept

Plot each graph on the same coordinate system.

4=

2=

4=

2= 4x + 12

4= 7x − 6

Two lines intersect to form 4 angles. Angles 2 and 4 are vertical angles with angle 2 = 4x + 12 and angle

A small airplane flies 750 miles with an average speed of 250 miles per hour. 1.75 hours after the plane leaves, a Boeing 747 leaves from the same point. Both planes arrive at the same time; what was the average speed of the 747?

Answers

Answer:

The average speed of the 747 was of 600 miles per hour.

Step-by-step explanation:

A small airplane flies 750 miles with an average speed of 250 miles per hour.

Velocity is distance divided by time, and here, we find the time of the small airplane. So

\(v = \frac{d}{t}\)

\(250 = \frac{750}{t}\)

\(250t = 750\)

\(t = \frac{750}{250}\)

\(t = 3\)

1.75 hours after the plane leaves, a Boeing 747 leaves from the same point. Both planes arrive at the same time;

This means that it traveled 750 miles in 3 - 1.75 = 1.25 hours.

What was the average speed of the 747?

\(v = \frac{d}{t} = \frac{750}{1.25} = 600\)

The average speed of the 747 was of 600 miles per hour.

24 = 3(n–5)

What is the answer​

Answers

Step-by-step explanation:

24=3n-15 or,25+15=3n or,39=3n or,39/3=n or,n=13 therefore the value of n is 13. I think this answer is helpful for you

Answer: n = 13

Step-by-step explanation:

24=3(n-5) - First  distribute the 3 to the n and the 5. Which you would than get 3n and -15

24=3n-15 - Now add the 15 to both sides which would cause it to cancel out on the left side of the equal side.

39=3n - Now divide the 3 from 3n on both sides of the equal side.

n=13 - Once you do that you will get n = 13. That is your answer!

Read paragraph 23.
(23) 'Of course some one might cut them down. The boy lowered his voice; it seemed shameful to mention the perpetration
of such a deed aloud. 'It would be terrible to hear them groan when the axe struck them. The young ones mightn't mind so
much; but it would be bad for the grandfather trees who've been here from the beginning. Hannah says one would still hear
them walling on stormy nights."
How does this paragraph add tension to the passage?

This excerpt adds tension by:

A.introducing Hannah's feelings toward the trees that were on the property and contrasting them with his own.
B. using the term "grandfather trees" to describe the older trees that have been on the property a long time.
C.emphasizing how painful it would be for the boy and the trees if the trees were cut down.
D. explaining how the old trees would take human qualities in reaction to being cut down.

Answers

This paragraph add tension to the passage by explaining how the old trees would take human qualities in reaction to being cut down. Option D

What is tension?

The term tension in literature has to do with the feeling of anxiety that comes along with a piece of written text. Anxiety is deliberately created by the author as one of means of making the reader to be spellbound by the writing.

Now, if we examine the excerpt as we have it in the question, we can see that this paragraph add tension to the passage by explaining how the old trees would take human qualities in reaction to being cut down. Option D

Learn more about tension in literature:https://brainly.com/question/16602460

#SPJ1

Pls help it is due today!!!!!

Pls help it is due today!!!!!

Answers

Answer:

BRUH THIS WAS ON MY TEST AND BRUH HONESTLY I HAVE NO CLUEE

Answer:

A

Step-by-step explanation:

Simplify:
A)
B)
C)
D)
8y - 2 - 3(y – 4)
lly - 6
5y - 6
5y - 14
5y + 10
I
36a
Write the fraction in lowest terms:
Please help. I’m reviewing algebra and i have no memory of this.

Simplify:A)B)C)D)8y - 2 - 3(y 4)lly - 65y - 65y - 145y + 10I36aWrite the fraction in lowest terms:Please

Answers

5y + 10

step by step :

8y - 2 - 3 ( y - 4)

8y - 2 -3y + 12

8y - 3y - 2 + 12

3y + 10

absolute value of v-5>3

Answers

Answer: v=8

Step-by-step explanation:

-5+5=0

3+5=8

v=8

find the perimeter of a circle whose diameter is 12.6 cm please help and show working​

Answers

Do you mean the circumference? You can’t find the perimeter of a circle. The circumstance of the circle is 39.584 to 3dp.

Answer:

39.584034 cm

Step-by-step explanation:

Firstly find the radius, 6.3 cm. Then plug into the formula, 2πr.

I used 3.14159 as pi.

work:

2 * 3.14159 * 6.3

6.28318 * 6.3

39.584034

What is the exponential form of 5x5x5x5x5?

Answers

Answer:

5

Step-by-step explanation:

The exponential form of multiplication 5x5x5x5x5 is, 5⁵

What is multiplication?

The fundamental concept of repeatedly adding the same number is represented by the process of multiplication. The results of multiplying two or more numbers are known as the product of those numbers, and the components that are multiplied are referred to as the factors.

The exponential form of a number raised to a power is written as the base number raised to the exponent, which is the power to which the base number is being raised.

In this case, 5 raised to the power of 5 can be written as 5⁵.

So, the exponential form of 5x5x5x5x5 is 5⁵.

To know more about multiplication check:

brainly.com/question/5992872

#SPJ5

Please help. Miguel had 2 bags containing number tiles as shown below. Without looking, Miguel selected one tile from each bag. What is the probability that Miguel selected two numbers less than 3?

Please help. Miguel had 2 bags containing number tiles as shown below. Without looking, Miguel selected

Answers

The probability of Miguel selecting a tile number less than 3 from each bag -1 is 1/5 and bag-2 is 2/5.

The given tiles in bag-1 = {2, 4, 5, 8, 9}

Total number of tiles in bag-1 = 5

The number of tiles less than number 3 in the bag - 1 = 1

The probability of Miguel selecting a tile number less than 3 =

number of tiles less than 3 / total number of tiles = 1/3

The given tiles in bag-2 = {0, 1, 3, 6, 7}

Total number of tiles in bag-2 = 5

The number of tiles less than number 3 in the bag-2 = 2

The probability of Miguel selecting a tile number less than 3 =

number of tiles less than 3 / total number of tiles = 2/3

From the above analysis, we solved the problem.

To know more about the probability,

https://brainly.com/question/25870256

#SPJ1

Match the term to its meaning.

Match the term to its meaning.

Answers

Answer:

Step-by-step explanation:

1. commission

2. percent

3. repeating decimal

4. terminating decimal

5. tip

Other Questions
PERSONALLY I thought it would be 98 Bc like yk..BUT I FEEL LIKE IM WRONGsend help beggin cryin throwin up I hate geometry so much Please help with math a marketing manager for a corporation is working with decision-makers to determine the deliverables for a marketing research project. in which stage of the market research process is the marketing manager? Ali has hired Mark and Alexis to work for his shipping company. Mark can load a truck with packages in 120 minutes. Alexis can load the same number of packages in 240 minutes. X/3=11?I forgot how to do this. Find what xy equals in problem #11 and how you got that answer The sum of 2 times p and 2 is 48. What is p? If there are 39 students and 4 have blue eyes what is the fraction? There are many "waves" in nature. Give a few examples andindicate whether they are longitudinal or transverse. I have two fair dice, eachnumbered 1 to 6I throw both dice and multiplythe two numbers togetherWhat is the probabilitythe number I get is a square number? The formula C=3. 14d can be used to approximate the circumference of a circle given its diameter. Company A manufacturers and sells a certain washer with an outside circumference of 9 centimeters. The company has decided that a washer whose actual circumference is in the interval 8. 8 what would not cause a long run supply of beef Please helppppppppppppppppppppppp Which of the following is used to treat candidiasis of the skin or mucous membranes? A) acyclovir B) miconazole C) trifluridine D) sulfonamide E) penicillin Why does Lady Macbeth drug the servants in Scene 2?She wants to stop them from killing King Duncan.She wants them to sleep while they kill King Duncan.She does not want their help in killing King Duncan.She wants them dead so they will not tell what they saw. Find the volume of the solid generated when the region bounded by y = 1 x ( 7 x ) , y = 0 , x = 2 , and x = 5 is revolved about the x-axis. Round your answer to four decimal places. A photon is emitted when an electron in a three-dimensional box of side length 7.751011 mm makes a transition from the nx=2nx=2, ny=2ny=2, nz=1nz=1 state to the nx=1nx=1, ny=1ny=1, nz=1nz=1 state. What is the wavelength of this photon? You are given the difference of the numbers of boys and girls in a class and the ratio of boys to girls. How many boys and how many girls are in the class?3 more boys; 5 for every 4 Which of the following is the most likely reason for a person to voluntarilymigrate?A. A war breaks out in that person's country.B. There are better job opportunities in another country.C. There are poor education opportunities in a new home nation.D. The government has ordered that person to move. tech a says that in modern vehicles, an oxygen sensor is only positioned in the exhaust pipe after the catalytic converter. tech b says that the oxygen sensor provides the electronic body control module (ebcm) with an electrical signal that relates to the amount of oxygen in the exhaust gas. who is correct?